GeneralMedium•20 November 2026•
4 min read

Judge Sends New York’s Case Against Kalshi Back to State Court After Federal Dispute

By

Key Facts

1The judge signed the order returning the case to state court on November 19, 2026.
2Kalshi reported in the state’s complaint a valuation of $22 billion and annualized transaction volume of $178 billion.
3The Commodity Futures Trading Commission ordered Kalshi to continue operating its platform on August 11, 2026.
4Court filings estimated the damages and costs sought by New York at about $36 billion when the case was filed in July 2026.

A federal judge in New York sent the state’s case against Kalshi back to state court in a judicial order signed on November 19, 2026, concluding that the federal court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction to consider the company’s request for protection from disclosure. The judge directed that the case be returned immediately to the New York Supreme Court in New York County, where the state is pursuing its allegation that the platform operated an unlicensed gambling business. The decision returns the dispute to the court where New York filed its case on July 31, 2026. The state had sought an injunction to stop Kalshi from operating as an unlicensed gambling company, along with fines, forfeiture of what it describes as illegal gains, and compensation for users. The remand order does not rule on the merits of the allegation or order the platform to shut down.

The remand followed Kalshi’s request for protection from disclosure in the case, but the judge said the lack of subject-matter jurisdiction prevented him from ruling on that request. The court clerk was ordered to close the pending motions and return the case immediately to the New York Supreme Court, New York County. The dispute has therefore returned to its state-court track, where the attorney general’s claims will be considered. Letitia James announced the case with New York Governor Kathy Hochul in July, accusing the platform of operating an illegal gambling business through its prediction market. The state is seeking to bar the activity within the scope of its case, as well as monetary relief related to it.

The state’s complaint sets out the scale of the activity at issue, saying Kalshi reported a valuation of $22 billion and an annualized transaction volume of $178 billion. The figures appear in the complaint as data reported by the company; they are not a court ruling on the platform’s value or the outcome of the case. The complaint also said Kalshi is not licensed by the New York State Gaming Commission in any capacity. The state cites that status in seeking to halt the platform’s operations as an unlicensed gambling business. The case thus links the characterization of the contracts offered by the platform with licensing requirements that New York says apply to them.

Among the objections raised by New York was that Kalshi’s markets are available, according to the state, to users aged 18 to 20. The state said its law requires participants in mobile sports betting to be at least 21. The allegation puts user eligibility among the state’s claims in the case, alongside the licensing issue. Court filings, according to an Associated Press report, estimated the damages and costs sought by the state at about $36 billion when the case was filed in July 2026. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission also said in August that New York’s request included a temporary order barring Kalshi from offering all event contracts nationwide, and damages exceeding $36 billion.

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission intervened on August 11, 2026, after Kalshi notified it of a market emergency linked to New York’s case, and directed the company to continue operating its platform in accordance with the core principles of the Commodity Exchange Act. The commission said the act makes it responsible for providing a unified national market for derivatives transactions, and that it works to protect market resilience and orderly trading. That directive preceded the November remand order: the commission issued its direction in August, and the judge signed the order returning the case on November 19. The different judicial and regulatory tracks reflect the continuing dispute between New York’s claims and the federal agency’s role in overseeing the derivatives market. The next step established by the available documents is the case’s return to the New York Supreme Court in New York County, where proceedings on the state’s case will resume.

Sources