EL7 Research · US Economy
30 September 2026
US consumer confidence fell to 81.9 points, its lowest level since 2014. A day later, official data showed that households increased spending by 0.9% in August. We compared what households say with what they do across five categories and measured how each release affected the probability of an October rate hike: survey pessimism did not move the market, but Williams’s speech and the inflation data did.
The Consumer Confidence Index (Consumer Confidence Index) published by The Conference Board fell to 81.9 points in September from 88.6 in August, its lowest level since 2014 and below every reading recorded during the 2020 pandemic shock. Consensus estimates (Consensus Estimates) stood at 89.2 points. The Expectations Index (Expectations Index) fell to 63.6 points, remaining below 80, the threshold the institution considers a signal of a possible recession within a year and which it fell below in February 2025.
But the hard numbers tell a different story. The next day, Bureau of Economic Analysis (Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA)) data showed that household spending rose 0.9% in August and 0.6% after adjusting for prices. Q2 economic growth was revised up to an annualised 2.2%, while consumer spending grew 3.8%. The unemployment rate remains at 4.1%, and the layoff rate at 1.0%.
The US consumer is therefore pessimistic in words but continues to spend. Households complain about prices and expect inflation of 6.1% over the next year, while actual inflation has not exceeded 3.4%. They are pessimistic about jobs even though companies are not laying off workers. This is what we call stagflation in sentiment, not in the data: inflation is indeed above target, but recession has so far appeared only in surveys.
The confidence report was not what moved the market. In Polymarket’s October decision contract, a prediction market (Prediction Market) where participants trade contracts on the decision’s outcome, as tracked by the EL7 database, the probability of a rate hike fell by only about 4 points after the report, then recovered most of the decline within three hours. The major drop followed a speech by John Williams (John Williams), president of the New York Federal Reserve, with the probability falling from 65.5% to 45.5% within 45 minutes. Personal Consumption Expenditures (Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE)) data then came in below expectations, pushing it down to 34%. Yet the probability of a December hike remained near 75%: the market deferred the hike; it did not rule it out.
A free account gives you 4 full research papers every month. Or subscribe to EL7 Pro for full access to more than 300 papers.
$700 per year · or $99 per month