CRUSH proposal targets $9 billion in annual recovery from Medicare Advantage payments
Key Facts
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, known as CMS, issued a proposed rule on November 16, 2026, to combat fraud, waste and abuse in Medicare, Medicaid, the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) and the health insurance marketplace. The agency estimates that the proposed audit approach could allow it to recover an average of nearly $9 billion in Medicare Advantage overpayments for each payment year. The proposal, called the Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare, or CRUSH, places particular emphasis on auditing payments to health plans run by insurers. CMS said the rule is separate and discretionary, not an annual payment rule. It added that it intends to conduct this type of program-integrity rulemaking annually.
In Medicare Advantage, CMS proposes revising audits of risk adjustments, including the use of an agency-determined sampling methodology and statistical extrapolation of audit findings to estimate recovery amounts. Under the proposal, extrapolation would begin with audits for payment year 2018. The agency also proposes removing the fee-for-service adjuster from these calculations. CMS says the measures would help it recover overpayments, and estimates average recoveries of about $9 billion per payment year. That figure is based on the proposed approach, while the rule remains open for public comment.
The proposal also addresses how information about suspected fraud is shared. CMS wants to require Medicare Advantage organizations and Part D plan sponsors to refer suspected or confirmed cases of fraud, waste and abuse to the agency, rather than leaving referrals optional. CMS cited data showing that only 46% of Medicare Part C and Part D plan contracts voluntarily reported referrals involving suspected or confirmed cases during 2025. Only 19% of those contracts also reported suspending payments based on credible allegations of fraud. The agency also proposes requiring states to collect, maintain and use National Provider Identifiers for all eligible Medicaid and CHIP providers. The data would cover enrollment, revalidation of eligibility, claims processing, managed care oversight, program integrity and reporting.
The plan would tighten deadlines for reporting changes to Medicare enrollment information. Current rules give providers and suppliers 30 calendar days to report critical changes and allow up to 90 days for some other changes. The proposal would require them to report any change in enrollment information within 30 calendar days. CMS also wants eligible providers and suppliers that bill Medicare Advantage to enroll in Original Medicare, with an exception for Programs of All-Inclusive Care for the Elderly (PACE). If adopted, these requirements would take effect on the first day of the plan year beginning two years after publication of the final rule. The implementation date therefore depends on when the final text is adopted and published.
CMS estimates that the proposal’s quantitative provisions would generate nearly $90 billion in federal budget savings combined, against estimated costs of about $378.51 million over the period from 2027 to 2036. The agency previously sought information on these issues on February 27, 2026, and then received more than 560 comments and suggestions, some of which it said helped shape the proposed rule. The record places the recovery and savings estimates within a broader package of program-integrity measures, rather than in a Medicare Advantage audit alone. The proposal was filed in the Federal Register under identifier CMS-6098-P. The Register set January 19, 2027, as the deadline for comments to be received for consideration.
The proposal comes as Molina Healthcare has already pointed to the impact of CMS program-integrity initiatives on its health insurance marketplace business. In its filing for the nine months ended September 30, 2026, the company said ongoing CMS initiatives contributed to unfavorable prior-year premium adjustments in its Marketplace segment. The segment’s medical care ratio was 88.3% for the nine months, compared with 87.9% in the corresponding period of 2025. In the third quarter of 2026, the ratio fell to 92.5% from 95.6% a year earlier. The company attributed the decline mainly to favorable changes in risk-adjustment premium estimates, partly offset by the acuity mix and CMS program-integrity initiatives. In the same third quarter, Molina recorded premium revenue of $10.5 billion, down 4% from the corresponding period, and a consolidated medical care ratio of 92.9%, compared with 92.6% a year earlier. The company reaffirmed its 2026 guidance for premium revenue of about $42 billion and adjusted earnings of at least $5.25 per diluted share.