U.S. Anti-Fraud Proposal Estimates $9 Billion in Annual Medicare Advantage Recoveries
Key Facts
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services issued a regulatory proposal to combat fraud, waste and abuse, estimating that its proposed audit approach for Medicare Advantage could allow the recovery of about $9 billion on average for each payment year. The agency said the proposal, known as CRUSH, was issued on November 16, 2026, and includes stronger oversight across Medicare, Medicaid, the Children’s Health Insurance Program and the health insurance marketplace. One of its main provisions focuses on auditing risk-adjustment data in Medicare Advantage, the program run by private insurers. The financial estimate represents potential total recoveries of excess payments across the program in each payment year. It does not specify a financial impact on UnitedHealth alone.
CMS proposes reforming audits of risk-adjustment data by using audit sample results to estimate overpayments at the contract level. Under the proposal published in the Federal Register, extrapolation would apply to audits for payment years beginning in 2018. This means findings from a sample could be used to estimate amounts owed at the level of the relevant contract. The proposal also says the fee-for-service adjuster would not be used in this process. CMS estimated that the new approach could allow the recovery of about $9 billion a year in excess Medicare Advantage payments.
The proposal would also require Medicare Advantage organizations and Part D plan sponsors to report suspected or confirmed fraud, waste or abuse referrals to CMS. The agency said reporting these referrals had been voluntary and that it wants to make it mandatory. In 2025, only 46% of Part C and Part D plan contracts voluntarily reported such referrals to CMS. That figure illustrates the scale of the proposed change to contract-level reporting requirements. The proposal also seeks to expand the information CMS receives about potential violations in federal health programs.
Alongside audits of Medicare Advantage plans, CMS proposes shortening the deadline for providers and suppliers to update enrollment information. The proposed deadline for reporting any change to enrollment information is 30 calendar days, while current rules allow up to 90 days for some other types of changes. CMS says the provisions in the proposal are intended to strengthen program integrity and reduce improper payments. The agency estimates that the proposal’s quantitative provisions could together generate nearly $90 billion in federal savings between 2027 and 2036. Over the same period, implementation costs are estimated at about $378.51 million.
CMS said the proposed rule is standalone and optional, and is not an annual payment-rate rule, but that it intends to conduct this type of program-integrity rulemaking annually in the future. It added that the proposal drew on more than 560 comments and suggestions received in response to a request for information issued in February 2026. Separately, on payment rates, CMS estimated in an earlier update that Medicare Advantage payments would rise by an average of 2.48%, or more than $13 billion, in 2027. That projected increase applies to payments to plans, while the CRUSH estimates concern potential recovery of overpayments. UnitedHealth said in its third-quarter 2026 report that consolidated revenue was $112.7 billion, compared with $113.2 billion in the third quarter of 2025.
In trading, UnitedHealth shares closed at $349.91 on November 18, 2026, after closing at $389.68 on November 17, according to EL7 data. In morning trading on November 18, Investing.com reported that the stock was down 4.2% at $373.47, extending a decline over several sessions amid the regulatory proposal. Prices for the November 19 session and the session low could not be verified from the available sources. In its third-quarter report, UnitedHealth said its UnitedHealthcare unit served 1.8 million fewer people year over year, citing benefit-design and pricing changes, reduced Medicaid eligibility and its exit from one state. The company also said core Medicare Advantage rates remained below the industry’s expected care-cost trend, although the final 2027 notice was approaching that trend.
The CRUSH proposal remains open for public comment. CMS is accepting comments for 60 calendar days after publication in the Federal Register and set January 19, 2027, as the deadline. The process allows affected parties to submit feedback before the regulatory process is completed. CMS said it intends to continue issuing program-integrity rules annually, although the current proposal is not an annual payment-rate rule. The recovery and savings estimates in the proposal remain tied to its proposed provisions until the comment process is complete.