UK court confirms notice requiring Apple to make user data available

Key Facts
The UK Investigatory Powers Tribunal confirmed that the government had issued Apple with a technical capability notice, but did not order the company to provide user data or rule on the legality of the access demand. The ruling came on Thursday as the tribunal considered whether the notice, known as a “technical capability notice,” could be publicly acknowledged. The tribunal said the government had not shown that disclosure of the notice to Apple would harm national security. The substance of the dispute, including the request to access encrypted data, remains outside the scope of the ruling. The tribunal is expected to consider the merits of the case next year, Reuters reported.
The dispute dates to January 2025, when Britain issued an initial notice allowing it to request access to encrypted cloud backups of data belonging to US and British citizens. The government dropped the initial request after months of negotiations with US President Donald Trump’s administration. It then issued a second notice in July 2026, limited to Apple customers in the UK. The two notices represent separate stages in the dispute: the first request expanded to cover cross-border data, while the second was limited to British users. The tribunal’s current ruling did not disclose details of the technical scope sought under the second notice.
Apple renewed its challenge against the government before the Investigatory Powers Tribunal, a specialist court, but was unable to publish details of its grounds of objection because of legal restrictions. The dispute over secrecy had reached earlier hearings; in September, Privacy International and Liberty said the government’s “neither confirm nor deny” policy obstructed open justice and public debate. The government’s lawyer replied that abandoning the policy could provide “material assistance to hostile actors.” The government had maintained that it would not comment on the notice’s existence on national security grounds. The current ruling allows its existence to be acknowledged without, by itself, disclosing its full contents or deciding Apple’s challenge to it.
Under UK legislation, notices require approval from a judicial commissioner, who also reviews the home secretary’s conclusions on the necessity and proportionality of the measure. The assessment includes consideration of privacy, alongside the principles governing judicial review. In February 2025, Apple withdrew its Advanced Data Protection feature for users in the UK and said it would not create a back door. The company warned that creating an entry point for one government could allow hackers or hostile states to exploit it, weakening users’ security generally. Liberty said the case could affect broader privacy rights in the future, and that opening a back door carries wide-ranging risks for personal data.
A UK government spokesperson, meanwhile, said Britain supports strong encryption and privacy protection, but added that law enforcement agencies must be able to access communications when necessary and proportionate. The spokesperson linked such access to protecting the public from terrorism, serious crime and child sexual abuse. This position sets protection of encryption and privacy against lawful access to communications when necessary. The ruling does not determine which side will prevail in the substance of the case; it was limited to whether the notice could be disclosed. A decision on the lawfulness of the request and its technical scope is deferred until the tribunal hears the substance of the expected challenge next year.
In the stock market, Apple shares closed at $352.45 in the November 18, 2026 session, up 0.15%, according to Reuters and EL7 data. The session data do not establish that the move was linked to the court ruling, and the Microsoft and Meta closing prices cited in the initial account of the news have not been verified. The share performance in the session provides a time-specific measure of trading, while any potential legal impact remains tied to the outcome of the challenge and what it could mean for the company’s encrypted services. The case is expected to move to a hearing on its substance next year, according to Reuters’ estimate. Until then, the current ruling has not determined whether Apple must make user data accessible or how that could be done.