Trump Downplays Huang Case in Xi Talks, Calls It a Tragedy Amid Chip Tensions
Key Facts
Donald Trump said the case involving Jensen Huang came up only briefly in his conversation with Chinese President Xi Jinping, describing what happened as a "tragedy" and the former Nvidia executive as a "brilliant man." Trump made the remarks in an interview broadcast by Fox News on Wednesday, after his talks with Xi at the APEC summit. He said they "didn't discuss it" and that he may have referred to it briefly because of what he called the tragedy. In the same interview, Trump said they discussed artificial intelligence over dinner and talked throughout the evening. His remarks place the case in the background of broader Washington-Beijing talks on technology and chips, as U.S. restrictions on China's access to advanced processors remain in force.
The case concerns Alice Huang, whom Reuters reported U.S. intelligence is trying to determine has ties to China's Ministry of State Security and what she may have transferred, citing people familiar with the matter. The agency did not say Alice Huang had been established as an intelligence agent, and reported that the Justice Department had not reached a conclusion about her links to the Chinese government. A Chinese foreign ministry spokesman denied the allegation, saying the espionage claim was "completely unfounded" and aimed at smearing China. The Associated Press reported that Alice Huang's company helped China gain access to advanced chips used to develop AI models, and that Beijing denied she was an agent of the Chinese government. Reuters also reported that Nvidia's independent board members hired a law firm to conduct an independent investigation into the case.
The controversy coincided with ongoing tensions over China's access to advanced chips, a matter the Associated Press described as a recurring point of friction between the two countries. Before the summit, analysts told Reuters that the possibility of tighter U.S. restrictions on China's access to AI chips could overshadow Trump and Xi's talks, while progress on AI safety cooperation remained possible. Washington issued temporary rules this week to restrict China's remote access to advanced chips hosted in overseas data centers. The Associated Press said tighter restrictions on remote access closed a channel that had enabled China to access Nvidia's advanced chips. At the opening of the APEC leaders' meeting, Xi called on the organization's 21 economies to unite in support of open trade and technology development.
The dispute also affects the trade truce between Washington and Beijing, set to expire on January 10, 2027, which reports said is under pressure from the fallout of the Nvidia case. The two sides had sought to advance tariff cuts on $30 billion of imports from each other through the U.S.-China Trade Council. But Reuters said in an earlier report that Washington and Beijing would not announce further progress on the initiative at the summit. In contrast, an Associated Press report said Kristalina Georgieva, managing director of the International Monetary Fund, told APEC leaders that AI is having a "tangible impact" on global growth and helping offset the effect of energy shocks. Chips and trade remain at the heart of tensions surrounding the two sides' economic relationship.
In the market, Nvidia shares fell 2.9% on Wednesday, November 18, after the company reported quarterly results, its first since Huang's removal, despite posting stronger-than-expected revenue and earnings. The stock closed at $150.96 that day, after closing at $155.46 on November 17 and $156.14 on November 16. It had recorded $162.85 on November 13 and $166.19 on November 12. The Associated Press linked the decline to the results and concerns about AI growth and turmoil in the company's leadership. Published data do not directly link the stock's drop to Trump's remarks or the diplomatic dispute with China.
In China, most participants in a Reuters poll expected the loan prime rates to remain unchanged in Friday's, November 20, review: 23 of 28 participants, or 82%, forecast the one-year rate would stay at 3.00% and the five-year rate at 3.50%. The other five participants expected one or both rates to be cut, and the review outcome had not been announced at the time of the report. The rates are calculated monthly after 20 designated banks submit proposals to the People's Bank of China. Reuters said limited expectations for further monetary easing followed the central bank's shift this month of its key policy rate to the overnight lending rate, a move analysts said eased financing conditions and supported the economy. Trump and Xi are expected to meet again at the G20 summit in Miami in December.