TELUS Evaluates Québecor Offer at C$19.45 per Share Amid Reservations
Key Facts
TELUS continues to evaluate the revised takeover offer submitted by Québecor, which valued it at about C$19.45 for each TELUS share, based on its share price on November 13. TELUS’s board had not decided whether to proceed with a transaction or maintain the status quo, according to a company disclosure. The proposal comes as TELUS shares had fallen 28% year to date before its announcement, according to Reuters. The company said its special committee is reviewing the offer’s value as well as regulatory approvals, governance, financing and leverage. TELUS proposed November 23 for a discussion of the proposal attended by the companies’ chief executives and chief financial officers.
The proposal includes C$6.35 in cash and 0.1700 Québecor Class B shares for each TELUS share. Québecor said this consideration is worth about C$19.45 per share, calculated using its share price on November 13. The company estimated that the offer includes a premium of about 60% to TELUS’s closing share price that day. This value and premium are based on Québecor’s share price on the specified date, while part of the consideration consists of shares. Québecor said the transaction could generate about C$160 million annually in operating synergies, in addition to C$235 million annually from capital efficiencies.
But TELUS’s board said the value, in its view, does not provide an appropriate premium given the company’s historical trading multiples, business profile and outlook. It added that the revised proposal’s valuation is also below levels for comparable Canadian telecom deals. This argument focuses on what the board considers an appropriate valuation for the company, rather than a final rejection of the proposal. TELUS said its shareholders would contribute most of the combined company’s economic value while receiving a minority of voting rights. The board described this disparity as a concern in its review of the transaction structure and governance.
TELUS’s reservations include the regulatory approval process and the allocation of related risks, as well as the governance structure. The company said its shareholders could remain exposed to fluctuations in Québecor’s share price during an extended regulatory review. It added that the implied premium at signing could differ significantly from the value shareholders receive upon completion. Accordingly, part of TELUS’s assessment of the proposal is tied to the risks between signing and closing, as presented in the company’s account of its position. The board has not announced a decision on the proposal and said it would continue its evaluation in light of its fiduciary duties.
On financing, TELUS’s board estimated that the combined company would start with net debt to EBITDA of about 4.1 times, based on Québecor’s estimates for 2027 earnings. TELUS said this level could limit the company’s ability to invest. It also noted that its shareholders would retain the benefits of efficiency initiatives already included in its plan. TELUS estimated that it would contribute about 74% of the combined company’s adjusted earnings for 2025, excluding TELUS Health. This places the company’s estimated operating contribution alongside the debate over how value, voting rights and financing would be allocated in the proposed transaction.
The precedent of Rogers’ acquisition of Shaw points to the challenges of reducing debt after major telecom deals. Rogers bought its rival for C$26 billion in 2023. S&P had expected the debt-to-EBITDA ratio to fall to 4 times by 2025, from 5.4 times immediately after the deal closed. But analysts now expect that level to be reached about three years later. Reuters cited this precedent in the context of risks associated with high leverage after a merger.
Analysts have also expressed doubts about the chances of a TELUS-Québecor deal closing. Jerome Dubreuil, an analyst at Desjardins, put the probability of closing at 25% in a report dated November 17. An analyst at RBC said obtaining regulatory approvals without significant remedies is unlikely in the current environment. These remain analysts’ estimates of the deal’s possible path, while TELUS’s board has not decided on its position. In market data, TELUS shares closed at $9.26 on November 17, according to EL7 data.
TELUS’s board received the initial proposal from Québecor on June 27, then received a revised version on November 9. The company said its special committee is reviewing the proposal and strategic alternatives, and that no decision has been made on whether to pursue a transaction or maintain the status quo. TELUS invited Québecor representatives to a meeting on November 23 to discuss the offer, with the chief executives and chief financial officers participating. The meeting is expected to allow both sides to discuss the proposal’s terms and the issues TELUS outlined in its disclosure. Until then, the offer remains under evaluation, according to the company’s stated position.