British Columbia Court Upholds Cancellation of KSM Substantial Start Determination, Requires Deep Consultation
Key Facts
On November 18, British Columbia Supreme Court Justice Emily Burke affirmed key elements of her June ruling on a petition by the Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation concerning the substantial start determination for Seabridge Gold's KSM project. The Nation said in a statement published via CNW that the determination was quashed because the Nation had not been consulted. The court said the province must conduct deep consultation, including consideration of potential impacts on its territory. The clarification makes completion of that process one of the steps required before the determination can be reconsidered. The judge did not rule on the reasonableness of the determination, according to the statement.
The consultation process extends beyond the 90-day deadline for written submissions, according to the Nation's statement. The end of that period does not mean deep consultation is complete, and no date has been set for its conclusion. This means reconsideration of the substantial start determination is not, for now, tied to an announced date for the end of consultations. The Nation's legal counsel, Ryan Beaton, said the clarification allows the parties to move forward with clarity on what the province and Seabridge are required to do. He added: "We can now move forward with clarity about what is required of the province and Seabridge."
In New York, Seabridge Gold shares, traded under the ticker SA, closed at $25.55 on November 18, compared with a close of $26.28 on November 17, according to EL7 data. These figures show the stock's movement between the two sessions, but do not establish that the court's clarification caused the decline. The Nation's statement also did not identify the reason for the trading move. The issue addressed in the ruling remains the scope of the required consultation and its effect on reconsideration of the substantial start determination. The statement gives no date for the end of that process.
Seabridge said on June 8 that the court had ordered the Environmental Assessment Office to provide a 90-day period for the Nation to submit written arguments, and then reconsider the substantial start determination. The company said at the time that work at KSM would continue during the consultation and the office's reconsideration. In September, it said the Environmental Assessment Office would allow it to respond to the Nation's submissions, then prepare a report and recommendation before the decision-maker reconsidered the determination. This sequence places consultation, the office's review and the decision-maker's ruling among the next procedural steps. But the Nation's statement clarified that the end of the submissions period does not end deep consultation.
The possibility of challenging the reasonableness of the substantial start determination remains open, according to the Nation's statement, because the judge did not rule on that basis. The statement also said the neighboring Gitxsan Nation withdrew its support for the KSM project after the original ruling, pending appropriate consultation by the province and Seabridge with Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha. This position connects part of the project's context to consultation with the Nations concerned. In its disclosure of the June ruling, Seabridge said work on the project would continue during the process, while reconsideration of the determination remained part of the proceedings it described. The ruling whose key elements were affirmed in November left the determination quashed because of inadequate consultation.
Alongside the judicial and regulatory process, Seabridge said in its report that a reconsidered decision may not be issued until late in the fourth quarter of 2026. The company set the end of 2027 as its target to complete a feasibility study for the KSM project, and said it continues to pursue a joint venture agreement with a major mining company with the technical, financial and social capabilities to support its development. During the third quarter of 2026, Seabridge invested about C$102.3 million in the project, compared with C$52.8 million in the same period of 2025. It also reported that the Treaty Creek Terminal was completed and began operating on August 27, 2026, describing it as infrastructure supporting the project. Feasibility study preparation included trade-off studies and assessments aimed at establishing the project's final description.