ECB Discusses Raising Reserve Requirement to 2%, With Potential Savings of €4.4 Billion
Key Facts
The European Central Bank’s Governing Council will discuss a proposal on November 25 to double the minimum reserve requirement for commercial banks from 1% to 2% of deposits and other short-term liabilities, Reuters reported, citing four sources. The decision could be deferred to the monetary policy meeting on December 17, meaning the increase remains a proposal under discussion. These funds are held in accounts that pay no interest, unlike other funds banks deposit with the central bank. Reuters estimated that raising the ratio could save the ECB and the national central banks participating in the euro about €4.4 billion a year at current interest rates. The calculations place lower interest costs and losses at the heart of the proposal’s financial rationale.
The main expected effect, according to Reuters, is to limit losses at central banks in the region, including the Bundesbank, as the cost of interest they pay on banks’ deposits rises when interest rates increase. The Eurosystem currently pays €52.2 billion a year on slightly more than €2 trillion in excess liquidity, the report said. Commercial banks receive no interest on required reserves, but earn the central bank’s deposit rate on other funds deposited with it. Raising the ratio would move a larger share of funds into a required, non-interest-bearing balance, reducing what central banks pay on liquidity held with them. The proposal is therefore tied to the cost of managing liquidity in the Eurosystem, rather than to an announced change in the main interest rate.
Estimates by the ING Global Economics team published via FXStreet on November 19 indicate that doubling the requirement could reduce excess liquidity by about €175 billion, from a total level the report puts at about €2.1 trillion. The estimate comes alongside ECB data showing excess liquidity of €2,078,023 million on November 17 and average reserve requirements of €177,314 million for the maintenance period running from November 4 to December 22. The figures show that the proposal would shift part of excess liquidity into required reserves, while most liquidity would remain outside that change based on the size of the published estimate. Reuters describes the absorption of some excess liquidity as an effect of the increase, while identifying lower central bank losses as the main expected effect. The estimated potential withdrawal therefore remains distinct from the annual savings Reuters calculated at current interest rates.
According to the ECB’s explanation, current requirements are calculated at 1% of specified liabilities on banks’ balance sheets, mainly including customer deposits and debt securities maturing in two years or less. This is the rule targeted by the proposal to raise the ratio to 2%, rather than all bank assets or funds. The ECB cut the requirement from 2% to 1% in 2012, amid pressure on banks from the sovereign debt crisis. This background shows that the proposed level would restore the ratio to the level in place before the cut, more than a decade after the change. Meanwhile, on October 29, the central bank kept its deposit facility, main refinancing and marginal lending rates at 2.50%, 2.65% and 2.90%, respectively.
Reuters says most Governing Council members currently support the idea, citing the report’s reference to backing from ECB Vice President Boris Vujčić and Chief Economist Philip Lane. But the proposal faces opposition within the Council: board member Pierre Wunsch warned in October that higher charges or reserve requirements could affect the credibility of central bank operations and perhaps approach the realm of fiscal policy. Wunsch said the case for raising reserves while keeping them unremunerated “is not clear or convincing to me.” The discussion comes as the ECB said in its November Financial Stability Review that euro zone banks are well placed to absorb shocks, thanks to earnings, capital and liquidity, while financial stability risks remain elevated. The central bank also said the share of excess reserves in banks’ liquidity buffers continues to decline as the Eurosystem’s balance sheet normalises.
The Governing Council is due to discuss the matter at its non-monetary policy meeting on November 25, according to the ECB calendar and Reuters sources. The Council will hold its monetary policy meeting on December 16 and 17, the date to which the decision could be deferred, according to the report. Some policymakers have also proposed delaying implementation of the increase until July, but Reuters said the option has not gained popularity. The report does not specify which year is meant by July, nor does it confirm a final implementation date. The move remains subject to the Council’s deliberations, while its expected financial and liquidity effects depend on the reserve ratio the ECB adopts and the timing of its implementation.