Canadian Court Order Expands Probe Into Old Navy and Gap Marketing Offers
Key Facts
The Canadian Competition Bureau has obtained a Federal Court order to gather information and advance its ongoing investigation into potentially false or misleading marketing claims by Old Navy and Gap, according to a Bureau statement published on November 18, 2026. The order requires the brands to provide records and written information relevant to the investigation. The measure allows the Bureau to continue examining practices it identified in product marketing, including how prices and offers are presented to consumers. The Bureau said explicitly that, as of the statement’s publication, the investigation had not resulted in any finding of a violation. The order therefore marks a step to gather evidence and continue the investigation; it is not a finding of wrongdoing by the brands or their operator.
The investigation focuses on whether prices described as “regular” are genuine when products are advertised as being on sale. The Competition Bureau’s guidance says an advertised regular price should meet one of two tests: more than 50% of the product must have been sold at that price or a higher price during a reasonable period, or the product must have been offered in good faith at the reference price for a substantial period. The first test refers to a reasonable period before or after the promotion, usually within one year. This review directly concerns the accuracy of the comparison shoppers see between the reference price and the sale price. The Bureau is therefore examining the basis for the advertised discount, not simply whether a discount label is present.
The review also covers signals that may prompt shoppers to make a quick decision, such as limited-time offers and countdown timers or clocks. The Bureau is also examining messages that suggest low stock, including “selling fast” and “only a few left.” These phrases appear among the Bureau’s examples of practices under review, alongside price offers. Their inclusion does not mean the Bureau has concluded they were misleading in the companies’ case; the statement describes the subject of the investigation while confirming that no finding of a violation has been made. This aspect brings e-commerce website messages and the presentation of product availability within the information the court order requires the brands to provide.
The Bureau is also checking claims about product popularity, including the number of people viewing or buying items, and statements related to former prices and discounts. Examples it cited include “price drop” and “best deal in 30 days.” This places price comparisons among the elements of the investigation, alongside demand and urgency indicators that may appear during shopping. The Bureau’s questions focus on the accuracy of these marketing representations, according to its description of the investigation’s scope. Whether any particular statement violated the law remains a question on which the Bureau has not yet issued a finding.
Gap Inc. operates Old Navy and Gap as separate brands, selling clothing and accessories through physical stores and e-commerce websites. This model puts both in-store offers and online marketing within the business channels described by the Competition Bureau. The Bureau previously said it saw an increase in complaints about inflated regular prices in 2025, and issued a warning reminding companies of their obligations under the Competition Act. It also published a consumer alert in 2024 ahead of Black Friday to raise awareness of false urgency signals. Those warnings provide context for the Bureau’s interest in reference prices and messages pressuring consumers, while the current investigation remains focused on the specific practices of the two brands.
The Bureau’s past records show that reference-pricing cases can end in financial settlements, without indicating the outcome of the current investigation. In a settlement announced on January 11, 2017, Amazon Canada paid a penalty of C$1 million, plus C$100,000 in Bureau costs, after an investigation at the time found that unverified list prices implied greater savings. At the company level, Gap Inc.’s latest reported results before the investigation showed net sales fell 2% year over year in the second quarter of fiscal 2026, ended August 1, 2026, while comparable sales declined 1%. The available information contains no finding on the investigation’s effect on sales or its expected outcome. Canadian retail sales data for September 2026 are due on November 20, with no reliable estimate of annual growth available.