1&1 asks European Commission to examine extension of German mobile spectrum licences
Key Facts
1&1 has asked the European Commission to examine whether extending German telecom operators’ spectrum usage rights constitutes unlawful state aid, according to a company statement issued on November 19, 2026. The company links its complaint to a decision by Germany’s Federal Network Agency that did not grant it access to frequencies below 1 GHz. 1&1 says the incumbent operators’ continued use of those frequencies puts it at a competitive disadvantage, as it relies on national roaming in some areas where it is expanding. It also says this arrangement denies it access to low-band spectrum even in areas where its network has towers. According to the company, the case is proceeding on two legal tracks: a request for European review and a referral of a legal question to the Court of Justice of the European Union. The information available contains no final decision by the Commission or court ruling in the case.
The dispute centers on how low-band spectrum is made available, which 1&1 considers important to expanding its network. Germany’s regulator said on February 17, 2026 that the three operators must negotiate with 1&1 on cooperative use of equivalent sub-1 GHz frequencies in areas where the company is expanding, while also opening a consultation on the possibility of requiring spectrum sharing. It invited interested parties to submit written views by March 18, 2026. This process indicates that the regulatory debate was not limited to 1&1’s request for dedicated frequencies, but also considered the possibility of sharing existing resources in specific areas. The proposed sharing applies to 1&1’s expansion areas, while national roaming covers Germany as a whole and can temporarily fill coverage gaps as the network is built.
Negotiations between 1&1 and the three operators over shared use continued through 2025 without an agreement, according to the consultation document published by the agency in February 2026. The document said that “the end of 2025 saw no agreement on implementing cooperative and shared use.” The agency said at the time that it would decide whether to impose sharing, putting the regulatory decision at the center of the dispute. In its technical assessment of sharing, the agency considered that national roaming within 1&1’s expansion areas could meet the requirements for cooperative use of equivalent sub-1 GHz frequencies. It also said the existing roaming agreement with Vodafone could count toward the obligation if it covered those areas, linking sharing requirements to actual coverage boundaries rather than simply the existence of a nationwide agreement.
The agency says its assessment of the telecoms market found effective competition in both the wholesale and retail markets, and therefore concluded that imposing an access obligation at the time would not be proportionate. This assessment highlights differing views of the existing framework’s effects: the company is challenging the treatment of the spectrum extensions and says its reliance on roaming constrains its competitiveness, while the agency based its position on its assessment of competition in both markets. The agency did not consider national roaming fully equivalent to geographic sharing: it explained that roaming covers all of Germany, while the proposed cooperative use is focused on 1&1’s expansion areas. On the other hand, it said the extensions give it room to offer a larger amount of spectrum in a later procedure and avoid a shortage that could arise under a smaller allocation framework. It added that the design of that procedure takes account of market developments and 1&1’s position.
The company says that continued roaming in areas where its network has towers means it is denied access to low frequencies there, potentially affecting the cost of network expansion. But the claim that fees charged to incumbent operators are below market value is 1&1’s position, not an independently established finding in the information available. The agency, in turn, said fees for extending the rights are imposed under Article 223 of the Telecommunications Act and its regulations on spectrum assignment fees. The dispute therefore also concerns the legal and economic basis for the extensions, in addition to the terms for sharing and roaming. The information available does not include verified closing prices for the companies’ shares in the November 18 and 19, 2026 sessions, so the legal action cannot be linked to a specific price reaction.
The regulatory context also includes the coverage obligations set by the agency in its 2025 decision. The decision required coverage of at least 99.5% of Germany’s area at speeds of at least 50 megabits per second from 2030. These requirements place network expansion and improved coverage within the framework in which companies will operate, while access to frequencies is one element of the debate over implementation and competition. The agency says the later competitive procedure may also include other rights expiring in 2033 within the extended frequency bands. The information available does not specify a date for that procedure or a possible outcome, while 1&1’s request to the Commission and the referral it says it made to the Court of Justice of the European Union remain part of the ongoing legal process.