EL7.AI
StocksMedium•19 November 2026•
3 min read

Humana shares fall 12.98% after US proposal to tighten healthcare program audits

Key Facts

1Humana shares closed at $385.78, down 12.98% on November 18.
2The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services estimated potential savings of about $90 billion over 10 years.
3The Medicare Advantage audit approach could enable recovery of about $9 billion on average for each payment year.
4The agency proposes extrapolating risk-adjustment audit findings starting with payment-year 2018 audits.

Humana shares closed at $385.78 on November 18, down 12.98% during the session, as attention grew around a proposed US regulation targeting fraud in government healthcare programs. The US Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services issued the proposed CRUSH rule on November 16, covering program integrity in Medicare, Medicaid, the Children’s Health Insurance Program and the health insurance marketplace. The agency said the measures could save taxpayers about $90 billion over the next 10 years. The proposal sets out a broad framework for strengthening oversight, while one of its key provisions focuses on auditing payments to Medicare Advantage plans. Humana’s decline comes as managed care companies face proposals that could change how data and payments are verified.

For Medicare Advantage, the agency proposes eliminating the fee-for-service adjustment factor when validating risk-adjustment data, establishing a sampling methodology, and then extrapolating audit findings starting with payment-year 2018 audits. CMS says this approach could enable it to recover an average of about $9 billion in overpayments for each payment year. Starting extrapolation in earlier years extends the scope of the audits proposed in the rule, rather than limiting them to recent reviews. The changes remain proposals and have not become final requirements. The agency has included efforts to address improper payments in its broader measures to protect public programs.

The rule also proposes requiring Medicare Advantage organizations and Part D plan sponsors to report referrals involving confirmed or suspected fraud, waste or abuse. The agency says it currently encourages such reports but does not require them. According to the agency’s review data, the reporting requirement is needed because practices varied in 2025: 46% of Part C and Part D plan contracts voluntarily reported referrals involving confirmed or suspected fraud, waste or abuse. Another 19% of those contracts reported having suspended any payments based on credible allegations of fraud. The rule proposes turning reporting from a practice encouraged by the agency into a requirement for the entities concerned if adopted.

CRUSH’s scope extends beyond Medicare Advantage audits, including changes to provider and supplier enrollment, oversight and eligibility for Medicaid and the Children’s Health Insurance Program, Medicare requirements for durable medical equipment suppliers, and oversight of health insurance marketplace agents and brokers. One proposal would require providers and suppliers that bill Medicare Advantage plans to enroll in Original Medicare. If finalized, this requirement would take effect on the first day of the plan year that begins after two years from publication of the final rule. That means the regulatory impact of this provision, if finalized, would not begin immediately upon publication. The agency’s estimated savings of about $90 billion cover the package of measures over 10 years.

In trading, 4.16 million Humana shares changed hands on November 18, compared with a 3.88% decline in the previous session, November 17. The stock had risen 2.50% on November 16, according to historical price data. The November 18 decline followed two sessions in which the stock moved in different directions and ended with a close at $385.78. Regarding 2027 Medicare policy, the agency said it would continue using the 2024 risk-adjustment model for 2027 payments, instead of the updated model proposed in the advance notice. This provides context on a separate track for 2027 payment policy, while the CRUSH rule remains a proposal.

Open on chart