TCIM’s 4.65% Stake Escalates Voya Board Vote Dispute
Key Facts
TCIM accused Voya Financial of trying to dissuade shareholders from participating in a poll asking them to express confidence in the board and management, and said the company had not complied with related filing and disclosure requirements. In a statement carried by StreetInsider from Business Wire, TCIM said Voya urged shareholders not to participate and that Broadridge Financial Solutions sent vote-summary reports to MacKenzie Partners, Voya’s proxy adviser, at the company’s direction. TCIM said these steps amounted to solicitation in violation of the rules, but that remains an allegation by a party to the campaign, not proof that a legal violation occurred. A filing by the company with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission said funds managed by TCIM represent an economic interest of about 4.65% in Voya. TCIM submitted its definitive proxy materials to some shareholders eligible to vote in an effort to rally participation in the poll.
TCIM scheduled the poll meeting for 24 November 2026 and said the proposed resolution is nonbinding, giving owners of common shares an opportunity to express confidence in the board and management. The definitive proxy filing shows that Voya does not endorse the meeting and that it is not being held under the special-meeting procedures set out in the company’s articles of incorporation and bylaws. In a statement issued on 24 September, Voya described the poll as "a private survey not sponsored by the company and unrelated to any actual shareholder vote." The company urged shareholders not to respond to any voting solicitation and said they could disregard any materials they might receive. TCIM’s filing also said 89,655,438 shares were outstanding and entitled to vote as of the 30 September 2026 record date.
TCIM is also grounding its campaign in criticism of board communications and the company’s stance on mergers and acquisitions. The company cited ISS as saying shareholders had expressed frustration over the lack of public communication and questioned how open Voya was to mergers and acquisitions. TCIM said Voya’s board did not appear willing to use the shareholder meeting to better inform them. By contrast, TCIM cited Glass Lewis as saying Voya had told the advisory firm it was open to credible acquisition offers. It added that the company had not commented on specific offers or particular rumors, while TCIM is urging the board to begin a formal review of strategic alternatives, including a sale of the company, and engage with interested parties.
Voya said on 24 September that shareholders had overwhelmingly supported the election of the board and executive compensation at the annual meeting held 4 months earlier. The company cites that prior vote in objecting to the private poll, while TCIM argues shareholders should have another opportunity to express their views. In its third-quarter 2026 results, Voya reported net income available to common shareholders of $193 million, compared with $176 million in the same period of 2025. Adjusted after-tax operating earnings were $240 million, compared with $239 million a year earlier, and the company said improved retirement and employee benefits earnings were partly offset by lower investment income and a $25 million pretax termination expense. Chief Executive Heather Lavallee said the results reflected the expected improvement in the second half and continued execution across the company’s businesses, pointing to "commercial momentum, margin improvement and expense management."
Voya also pointed to an increase in retirement-segment client assets to $878 billion on 30 September 2026, from $785 billion on the corresponding date a year earlier, while the number of retirement plan participants reached 10.3 million. On 2 November, the company announced a 21% increase in its quarterly cash distribution per share to $0.57, effective in the fourth quarter of 2026, along with a $500 million increase in its share-repurchase authorization. Voya is presenting these indicators as its dispute with TCIM continues over how the poll is presented to shareholders and what it means. The poll meeting is scheduled for 24 November 2026, when shareholders will vote on the nonbinding advisory resolution. Until then, the dispute centers on shareholder participation, the nature of the process and how responsive the board is to the campaign’s demands.