Appeals Court Upholds Rejection of Kalshi’s Bid Over Sports Contracts in Maryland
Key Facts
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit on November 17, 2026, upheld the denial of Kalshi’s request for a preliminary injunction barring Maryland gambling regulators from applying state laws to its sports markets, according to Bloomberg Law. The ruling affirmed a 2025 decision by the federal district court, which denied the platform the temporary protection it sought. The dispute concerns sports event contracts offered by Kalshi, not prediction markets as a whole or every type of contract traded on the platform. The court concluded that these markets are “likely subject to Maryland gambling laws.” The decision leaves enforcement of those laws in place in this case, as debate continues over which authority has regulatory power over sports contracts traded on prediction platforms.
Kalshi’s request before the appeals court sought to halt action by Maryland gaming regulators while the dispute was pending, so the ruling addressed the denial of preliminary relief, not a comprehensive final judgment on all legal issues involving the platform. The Fourth Circuit thus affirmed the lower court’s 2025 decision without establishing a general rule that applies to all prediction markets or contracts. The case focuses on the connection between sports event contracts and state gambling laws. The significance of this distinction is that the question before the court concerned a specific type of contract and the jurisdiction of Maryland regulators. The ruling therefore resolves only the outcome of Kalshi’s preliminary request in this dispute.
The disagreement extended beyond the outcome of the preliminary request to a broader question about the division of authority between the federal government and the states. The judges’ opinions addressed whether sports prediction markets fall under the exclusive regulatory jurisdiction of the federal Commodity Futures Trading Commission, or may also be subject to state law. The hearing described the central question as whether the Commodity Exchange Act preempts the application of Maryland gambling laws to sports event contracts traded on an exchange. The Fourth Circuit had heard arguments from Kalshi in the dispute on May 7, 2026. The tension between federal regulation of derivatives and the states’ traditional authority to regulate gambling thus remained at the center of the case.
The appeals ruling came from a divided panel, with each of its three judges issuing a separate opinion on the regulatory issue. The multiple opinions reveal differing approaches to the relationship between federal commodities rules and Maryland’s authority over sports contracts, even as the ruling affirmed the denial of the preliminary injunction. The split does not undo the outcome in the case, but places it within an ongoing judicial debate over the limits of jurisdiction. The issue centers on whether describing a contract as exchange-traded places it exclusively under the oversight of the federal agency, or leaves room for local gambling laws to apply. Within the scope of the case before it, the ruling did not provide a general rule covering all contracts or states.
Kalshi’s broader position is that prediction markets fall exclusively under federal jurisdiction and are not governed by a patchwork of state gambling laws, according to the Associated Press’s reporting on a separate case in Utah. In that case, a federal judge rejected the platform’s request to halt the restrictions, and the company said it planned to appeal the ruling. The agency reported that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission had defended prediction markets in court. Those facts remain tied to the Utah dispute and do not change the scope of the Maryland ruling on sports contracts and state law. The Maryland ruling also does not by itself establish an operational effect on Kalshi or a uniform outcome for disputes being heard in other states.
The Maryland case is part of a series of disputes involving proceedings in other states, with different parties, facts and outcomes. EL7 reported in July on a separate dispute in which a court rejected Kalshi’s request to halt New York gambling laws. Kentucky also sued Kalshi, Polymarket and their partners over sports contracts that the state said were illegal. In another dispute, a U.S. appeals court upheld states’ right to regulate prediction markets as gambling. These cases do not make the Maryland ruling a general judgment on other disputes; the Fourth Circuit’s decision addressed a specific preliminary request and sports contracts in one state.