EL7.AI
CryptoMedium•17 November 2026•
4 min read

Brothers acquitted in case over extracting $25 million from Ethereum transactions in 12 seconds

Key Facts

1Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted the brothers in a case involving the extraction of $25 million from Ethereum.
2The court said prosecutors had not proved the material deception required for a wire fraud case.
3Prosecutors said the alleged operation took place in April 2023 and lasted about 12 seconds.
4The first trial ended in a mistrial in November 2025 after the jury failed to reach an agreement.

A U.S. federal judge on Monday, November 16, acquitted brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud and related charges in a case involving the extraction of $25 million in value from Ethereum transactions. Bloomberg reported that Judge Jessica Clarke concluded the brothers had not made false statements to carry out what prosecutors described as a scheme to exploit a software bug, enabling them to obtain the amount in 12 seconds. The ruling came after the defense asked the court to dismiss the case, with the court finding that the government had not proved the material deception required to establish wire fraud. The charges included conspiracy to commit wire fraud, wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. The decision spares the brothers a retrial after the jury in the previous trial failed to reach a verdict.

The Block said the core of Clarke's decision was the lack of evidence that the brothers made materially misleading representations while carrying out the operation. The ruling therefore focused on the evidentiary element required for the fraud charges before the court, rather than making a comprehensive determination on all forms of value extraction through transaction ordering. Cointelegraph quoted the judge as saying the transactions involved no false promises and did not amount to criminal fraud in the case before her. She also said the question was not whether the brothers' conduct was ethical or whether it might violate other laws. This scope defines what the court decided in the case without turning the ruling into a blanket endorsement of the legality of every strategy involving MEV.

The events prosecutors attributed to the brothers date to April 2023, when prosecutors said they lured sandwich-style trading bots into transactions and then disabled them to obtain cryptocurrency. According to the prosecution's account reported by Cointelegraph, an alleged vulnerability in MEV-Boost software was used to carry out the operation in about 12 seconds. The ruling did not establish that the brothers exploited a software flaw; the flaw was part of the prosecution's allegation in the case. MEV refers to the maximum value that can be extracted from a decentralized finance protocol or smart contract by ordering transactions. That mechanism puts transaction ordering at the center of the dispute, but the ruling addressed whether the facts established fraud and deception under the specific charges.

The criminal case began more than two years before the ruling, with the brothers arrested in May 2024 after prosecutors accused them of exploiting the Ethereum network. The U.S. Department of Justice said when announcing the charges that the case involved a scheme it described as novel and one for which no similar charge had previously been brought, while emphasizing that the allegations in an indictment are not proof of guilt. The indictment says planning began in December 2022 and that the brothers used bait transactions to identify targeted MEV bots. These details represent prosecutors' allegations about preparations for the operation, not independent findings made by the court in its acquittal ruling. The judicial outcome remains tied to the charges the court considered and whether their elements were proved.

The first trial ended in a mistrial in November 2025 after the jury failed to agree on whether to convict or acquit the brothers. Reuters, in a report carried by Investing.com, said jurors could not agree on a verdict, while Cointelegraph reported that the deadlock led to a mistrial. After Clarke's ruling, the brothers will not be retried in the current case, according to Bloomberg. The outcome brings the criminal proceedings before the court to an end after the jury deadlocked in the first attempt. But, according to coverage of the judge's remarks, it does not resolve every legal or ethical question that might relate to their conduct beyond the charges on which the ruling was issued.