EL7.AI
StocksMedium•17 November 2026•
4 min read

CMS Proposes Recovering About $9 Billion a Year From Medicare Advantage Payments

Key Facts

1CMS issued the CRUSH proposal on November 16, 2026.
2CMS estimates average recoveries of nearly $9 billion per payment year by expanding Medicare Advantage audits to payment year 2018.
3CMS says the proposal could save nearly $90 billion over 10 years.
4Only 46% of Part C and Part D contracts voluntarily reported suspected or confirmed fraud referrals during 2025.
5The number of people covered by UnitedHealth's Medicare Advantage program fell 10% to 7.605 million on September 30, 2026.

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) on November 16, 2026, issued the CRUSH proposal, a new rule to strengthen oversight of fraud, waste and abuse in Medicare, Medicaid, CHIP and the health insurance marketplace. The text proposes expanding the scope of risk adjustment data validation audits in Medicare Advantage, allowing the agency to extrapolate audit findings to earlier payment years. CMS estimates that this approach could enable it to recover an average of nearly $9 billion for each payment year. The agency says the proposal could save taxpayers nearly $90 billion over 10 years. These are estimates tied to a proposal that has not yet become a final rule.

CMS proposes codifying its risk adjustment data audit methodology, including not applying a fee-for-service adjuster and expanding extrapolation to audits for payment year 2018. This is linked to the RADV program, which the agency describes as its primary means of addressing overpayments to Medicare Advantage plans. The program checks whether medical records support the diagnoses used in risk adjustment. The proposed extrapolation would extend audit findings beyond the records directly reviewed, according to CMS's estimate. The agency reports potential average recoveries of nearly $9 billion per payment year, not amounts already collected.

The proposal would also require Medicare Advantage organizations and Part D plan sponsors to refer suspected or confirmed cases of fraud, waste and abuse to CMS. The agency says only 46% of Part C and Part D contracts voluntarily reported such referrals during 2025. Just 19% of those contracts also reported suspending payments based on credible allegations of fraud in the same year. The rule proposes expanding mandatory reporting of payment suspensions to include all types of providers and suppliers. The reporting requirements, according to CMS, are based on a July 2018 recommendation from the Office of Inspector General to establish a centralized system for reporting incidents of fraud and abuse and corrective actions in Part C and Part D.

CMS says CRUSH is a standalone discretionary rule, not an annual update to Medicare Advantage payments. The proposed changes cover enrollment and oversight in Medicare Advantage, Part D, Medicaid and CHIP, as well as medical equipment suppliers and health insurance marketplace brokers. Public consultations preceded the proposal: on February 27, 2026, the agency solicited views on anti-fraud changes and received more than 560 comments and proposals, some of which it said helped shape the rule. The text also proposes requiring eligible Medicare Advantage providers and suppliers to have an approved enrollment status in original Medicare, with an exception for Programs of All-Inclusive Care for the Elderly (PACE). If adopted, the requirement would take effect on the first day of the plan year beginning two years after publication of the final rule.

The proposal comes as UnitedHealth faces pressure in its Medicare Advantage business. In its third-quarter report, the company said funding pressure had led to changes in benefits and pricing and a contraction in program membership, while higher care patterns and health unit costs weighed on the sector. The number of people covered by its Medicare Advantage plans fell 10% to 7.605 million on September 30, 2026, from 8.435 million on the same date in 2025. Government payments to Medicare Advantage plans also rose by an average of 5.06% between 2025 and 2026, an increase of 2.83 percentage points from the initial 2026 notice, according to CMS. The documented facts available here do not include reliable data confirming UnitedHealth's share movement in the November 17 session or identifying a cause.

Against the backdrop of economic data released on November 17, U.S. retail and food services sales rose 0.2% in October to $748.2 billion, compared with a revised 0.8% increase in September. The Census Bureau noted that the confidence interval for the monthly change includes zero. The figure is for October, despite being released in November, and does not establish a link to UnitedHealth's share movement. The advance report on November retail sales is scheduled for release on December 16, 2026. The deadline for public comments on the CRUSH proposal is January 19, 2027.

Open on chart