Strategy’s Exclusion from MSCI Indexes Puts Pressure on Investment Flows as Bitcoin Value Falls
Key Facts
MSCI indexes are set to remove Strategy A from the MSCI USA Index at the close of trading on November 30, in a move Reuters said came after the company concluded that Strategy and other firms were more akin to investment funds. The November review showed this was the first application of the non-operating companies methodology, and the deletions included 3 companies from the MSCI ACWI IMI. In a November 16 update on its bitcoin holdings, Strategy’s reserve was valued at $58.571 billion, against a total acquisition cost of $64.198 billion. The decision comes as bitcoin trades below the company’s average cost of $75,452 per coin, according to data as of November 17. MSCI had set October 20 as the price reference date for the review, with the changes due to take effect at the end of November.
Reuters said MSCI cited the characteristics of companies that resemble funds, a category excluded by the relevant index criteria. According to Reuters, Strategy’s model relied on issuing debt and shares to fund its bitcoin accumulation, giving investors indirect exposure to the cryptocurrency while leaving the company exposed to its price swings. Strategy estimated that its exclusion could lead to $2.8 billion in share sales. JPMorgan estimated that outflows could reach $8.8 billion if other index providers followed MSCI’s decision. These estimates depend on how widely the deletion extends to other indexes, while Reuters said the decision could limit passive investment flows into the affected shares.
In its latest filing, Strategy said it bought 485 bitcoin for $33.4 million during the period from November 9 to 15, at an average price of $68,887 per coin. Its total holdings consequently reached 850,849 bitcoin as of November 15, at an average acquisition cost of $75,452 per unit. The company said the bitcoin purchases were funded from the net proceeds of MSTR share sales. During the same week, it sold 2,087,040 MSTR shares and raised net proceeds of $244.7 million. It allocated the proceeds among $33.4 million for bitcoin purchases, $206.3 million to repurchase STRC preferred shares, and $5.0 million added to its dollar cash balance. This breakdown shows that the largest portion of the proceeds from share sales during that period did not go toward buying bitcoin.
Bitcoin fell to $64,666.5 on November 17, after touching about $62,000 over the weekend, its lowest level in four months, according to Investing.com. The site said the cryptocurrency had posted losses for 6 consecutive weeks, as strong U.S. inflation data bolstered bets on a Federal Reserve rate hike in December. As for the stock, Reuters reported that Strategy shares fell 2.5% in extended trading on November 11 following news of MSCI’s decision. The company’s shares had fallen about 20% year to date through November 11, compared with a 15% decline in bitcoin over the same period. Investing.com said the exclusion could limit Strategy’s ability to raise capital, potentially affecting its ability to continue buying bitcoin.
MSCI’s review schedule calls for the derived indexes to be announced on November 18, while market capitalization index changes take effect after the close on November 30. In a statement on the review results, MSCI confirmed that all changes would be implemented at the close that day. The timetable allows investors to know when the deletion will be applied, while the estimated effect on flows remains tied to decisions by other index providers. Strategy’s warning of $2.8 billion in share sales specified the impact of the exclusion that the company expects. JPMorgan’s estimate of $8.8 billion assumes that other providers follow MSCI. This places the announcement of the derived indexes on November 18 ahead of the implementation deadline at the end of the month.