Letter from U.S. lawmakers raises questions over Nvidia’s advanced chip sales to China
Key Facts
Sen. Ron Wyden and Rep. Richard Neal asked the U.S. commerce secretary to preserve records related to export licenses for Nvidia chips and the department’s communications with the company and its CEO, Jensen Huang. The request was made in a letter dated November 12, according to the Senate Finance Committee, amid a debate over advanced chips reaching Chinese companies. The lawmakers wrote that the department had approved sales to Chinese companies with government and military ties, including shell companies they said had no actual presence at their registered addresses. These allegations remain attributed to the letter and are not the stated findings of an independent investigation. The letter highlights how U.S. export restrictions are applied and the possibility that intermediary companies could be used to access advanced computing capabilities.
The letter places these concerns in the context of U.S. policy allowing some applications to export chips to China to be reviewed on a case-by-case basis. On January 13, 2026, the Commerce Department’s Bureau of Industry and Security announced a change in its licensing review policy for Nvidia H200 and AMD MI325X chips and similar processors, subjecting applications to security conditions. These include showing that exports would not reduce the global capacity available to U.S. customers, as well as compliance measures by the Chinese buyer and customer screening. The products must also undergo independent testing by a third party in the United States to verify their performance and security. The department said license applicants must demonstrate that these measures, including customer screening, have been adopted and that testing has been completed in the United States.
The lawmakers’ letter addressed a proposed route for selling H200 chips manufactured in Taiwan to China. According to the letter, the route would have required the chips to be sent first to the United States for a security review and licensing before being re-exported to Chinese buyers. The letter added that the administration imposed a 25% fee on the chips when they entered U.S. territory, describing it as a deduction from Nvidia’s sales to China through an export tax that it said appeared unconstitutional. These are descriptions and allegations made by the lawmakers in their letter about the sale arrangements and fees. The available materials did not include a response from the department to these allegations.
Public comments by U.S. officials point to differences within the administration over whether entities linked to chip trading should be placed on export restriction lists. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told The Associated Press that his department, the State and Defense departments, and the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative had supported placing Singapore-based Megaspeed International on the restrictions list for months, while the Commerce Department had the decision. Bessent added: "The Commerce Department is the decision maker, and you have to ask them about their internal process." The AP reported that Megaspeed had bought more than $4 billion worth of advanced Nvidia chips while under investigation over allegations that it had transferred chips to China. The Bureau of Industry and Security began investigating the company in 2024, before the case was later referred to the Justice Department, the AP reported.
Some in Congress are seeking to consider additional restrictions on exports of advanced artificial intelligence chips to China. Reuters reported that House Speaker Mike Johnson said growing agreement was taking shape in Congress to limit chip exports to China. It also reported that Republican lawmakers want to include new restrictions in the annual defense authorization bill. Pending legislation includes proposals to give Congress a greater role in export decisions and require companies to track the locations of advanced processors. Other proposals would give the Commerce Department tools to prevent Chinese companies from renting data centers outside China to access Nvidia chips, a loophole directly tied to concerns about indirect access to computing.
The debate coincided with pressure on technology stocks in Asian markets on Monday, November 16, as investors awaited Nvidia’s earnings report, due Tuesday, November 17, according to The Associated Press. South Korea’s Kospi fell 3.6% to 5,100.50, with SK Hynix down 7.9% and Samsung Electronics down 4.5%. The AP said most Asian stocks fell as a technology selloff resumed. In the previous U.S. session, Nvidia shares fell 2% on Friday, November 13, after dropping 4.3% on Thursday, November 12, when the company announced Huang’s resignation, the AP reported. The AP said the resignation raised U.S. national security concerns, while official Chinese data released on Monday, including retail sales and industrial production, came in below analysts’ expectations.
Attention is next expected to turn to a hearing requested by House Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Brian Mast for December 2 on computer chip smuggling and reported interference in export control policies and investigations. The request comes as calls grow in Congress to tighten oversight of advanced chip export routes. Wyden and Neal’s letter focuses on preserving records of licensing decisions and the department’s communications with Nvidia and Huang. Together, these efforts bring scrutiny of licensing decisions alongside consideration of ways to monitor chip use after sale. The review of H200 and MI325X exports remains subject to the security conditions announced by the Commerce Department in January.