Land & Buildings Values Invitation Homes’ Homes at About $425,000 Each and Calls for Annual Distributions
Key Facts
Land & Buildings issued an open letter to Invitation Homes shareholders on November 16, calling on the board to move faster to enhance shareholder value. The investment firm estimated that Invitation Homes’ homes were worth about $270,000 each at the share price when the letter was issued, roughly 40% below the value it derives from recent sale prices. Its estimate was based on an individual valuation of more than 90% of the wholly owned homes, averaging about $425,000 each. It arrived at a net asset value of about $45 per share after deducting a 6% selling cost. Land & Buildings said the board had not acted as quickly as shareholders deserved, according to its open letter.
The investor’s call centers on returning capital by selling homes individually when the stock trades below estimated net asset value. The letter called for an annual commitment to return at least $2 billion to shareholders through share repurchases or distributions, on a leverage-neutral basis. It also proposed funding these payments with proceeds from home sales, linking the proposal to the discount it sees between the share price and the value of the assets. The proposal would shrink the portfolio and accelerate capital returns, while the company is selling homes and using part of the proceeds to repurchase shares. The letter did not present these demands as a plan approved by the board.
Land & Buildings also proposes giving current tenants a 6% discount when they buy their home to help cover the down payment. The letter also calls for reducing external acquisitions and development, in line with directing resources toward asset sales and capital returns. The investment firm said the average gross sale price of homes since December 2025 was about $460,000. Invitation Homes also reported that the average gross sale price of homes sold over the same period was about $460,000, compared with an implied value of about $280,000 per home when shares were repurchased. The company said it repurchased 36,923,753 shares at an average of $26.78 per share between December 1, 2025, and October 27, 2026.
The activist investor’s demands overlap with a program the company is already pursuing, but the letter sets out a more specific scale and pace. In the third quarter of 2026, Invitation Homes sold 658 wholly owned homes and bought 216, a net reduction of 442 homes. The company said the net proceeds, about $245 million, were used to fund share repurchases. It also said buybacks would continue to be funded with home-sale proceeds when the stock trades at a material discount to the value of the homes, subject to market conditions and balance-sheet discipline. Land & Buildings is calling for an annual commitment of at least $2 billion, setting a minimum amount for capital returns that the company’s plan in its filing does not specify.
The letter followed operating results showing growth in revenue and net income, alongside divergent trends in rents, operating expenses and occupancy. Comparable annual revenue in the third quarter rose 6.3% to $731 million, while net income available to common shareholders increased 15.6% to $158 million, or $0.27 per diluted share. Core FFO per share rose 2.4% to $0.48, while AFFO per share increased 0.1% to $0.38. The company attributed Core FFO growth mainly to a lower share count after repurchases and growth in same-home net operating income. That measure grew 1.1%, with core revenue growth of 1.6% and core operating expenses rising 2.5%.
For occupancy and rents, average same-home occupancy was 96.4% in the third quarter, down 10 basis points from a year earlier. Renewal rents rose 4.3%, while new-lease rents fell 0.2%, bringing blended rent growth to 3.0%. Meanwhile, the company raised the midpoint of its 2026 annual Core FFO guidance by one cent to $1.96 per share. It also raised its same-home net operating income growth outlook to 1.2% and its wholly owned home sales outlook to $950 million. These figures provide operating context for the debate over home sales, while the investor’s letter is based on asset values and capital allocation.
Land & Buildings said the stock had lagged market indices and peers over one-, three- and five-year periods, and ranked second to last among its compensation peer group over the prior three years, trailing the group average by more than 35 percentage points. In the latest session before the letter, INVH shares closed at $26.85 on November 13, up 0.75% from the November 12 close of $26.65. The board had decided on November 9 to increase its size from 9 to 10 members and appoint Colin Connolly, whose term began on November 13. Land & Buildings said it remained open to working with the company, but believed a significant change would be necessary if the board did not act decisively and in a timely manner. The letter thus puts capital-return proposals before shareholders, while management is already pursuing buybacks funded by home sales.