EL7.AI
GeneralMedium•16 November 2026•
3 min read

KOGAS Ordered to Pay 268.46 Billion Won in Appeal Over LNG Carrier Defects

Key Facts

1The total compensation the Seoul High Court ordered KOGAS to pay was 268.46 billion won.
2SK Shipping received 220.39 billion won on appeal, compared with 115.4 billion won at first instance.
3Samsung Heavy Industries’ compensation on appeal was 48.07 billion won, down from 72.6 billion won at first instance.
4The two appeal rulings were issued on November 11.

On November 11, the Seoul High Court ordered Korea Gas Corporation, known as KOGAS, to pay a total of 268.46 billion South Korean won in compensation to SK Shipping and Samsung Heavy Industries, in an appeal ruling over technical defects in two liquefied natural gas carriers. Compensation for SK Shipping was set at about 220.39 billion won, compared with 48.07 billion won for Samsung Heavy Industries. The ruling followed compensation lawsuits filed by the two companies in 2019 over technical problems with the domestic KC-1 containment system. Chosunbiz published details of the ruling on November 13, while Yonhap coverage confirmed the appeal decision was issued on November 11. The ruling imposes substantial financial liability on KOGAS for defects the court said prevented the vessels from operating as LNG carriers under their transportation contracts.

The appeal produced different outcomes for the two companies compared with the first-instance ruling. Compensation for SK Shipping rose to 220.39 billion won, an increase of about 105 billion won from the 115.4 billion won awarded by the lower court. In contrast, the appeal cut Samsung Heavy Industries’ compensation to 48.07 billion won from 72.6 billion won in the previous ruling. The appeal therefore increased the amount awarded to the shipping company while reducing what the shipbuilder is entitled to receive. The difference reflects the court’s assessment of each claim separately, while the total compensation in the appeal remained 268.46 billion won.

The court relied on the “cold spot” defect in the KC-1 system, with the appeals panel saying it was a fundamental defect that could cause sudden brittle fracture in the vessel’s structure. The defect concerns a section of the structure cooling below the permitted minimum, according to details of the ruling. The court found that the flaw prevented the carriers from operating as LNG carriers under their transportation contracts. It also held KOGAS responsible for damage related to moisture in the cargo tanks and cracks in the plywood. The court said the vessels “cannot operate as liquefied natural gas carriers under the transportation contracts,” directly linking the technical defects to the disruption of their contracted use.

The appeals panel rejected KOGAS’s argument that Samsung Heavy Industries should bear part of the responsibility for the defects. The court said the company’s involvement in some aspects of development, even if established, did not limit KOGAS’s liability. In a separate case, KOGAS lost its claim against SK Shipping over the failure to provide replacement vessels. The court also rejected that claim, as the lower court had done. The appeal ruling therefore not only determined the compensation owed to the two companies, but also upheld the rejection of KOGAS’s separate claim against the shipping company.

The background to KC-1 goes back to a project to develop domestic tanks for LNG carriers, with joint research beginning in 2004. KOGAS said the development of Korean tanks followed 10 years of research cooperation between it and Korean shipbuilders. The technology was presented as a domestic product intended to localize this part of the LNG carrier industry. But the court dispute ended with compensation for defects in the two vessels, according to the appeals court’s findings. The ruling places responsibility for the disputed damages on the company, despite the shipbuilder’s involvement in some stages of development.