U.S. Judge Rejects Bid to Dismiss DRAM Suit, Keeps Collusion Claims Under Review
Key Facts
On November 14, 2026, Judge Noel Wise of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California rejected Samsung, Micron and SK hynix’s bid to dismiss a proposed class action over the DRAM memory market. The ruling keeps the case alive at the stage of assessing the sufficiency of the complaint, after the court found that plaintiffs had plausibly alleged a conspiracy under Section 1 of the Sherman Act. It is not a finding that the companies actually agreed or are liable for an antitrust violation. The court wrote in its order: "The Court finds that Plaintiffs have done so here." The ruling puts the allegations on the next stage of litigation, setting a deadline for the companies’ responses and a case management conference.
The lawsuit concerns four practices that the complaint alleges contributed to restricting supplies of conventional memory. The claims include simultaneous production cuts between October 26, 2022, and April 7, 2023, followed by a coordinated shift toward high-bandwidth memory, or HBM, that began in March 2023. The complaint also alleges that the companies coordinated their exit from DDR4 and DDR3 production during 2024 and 2025. The fourth claim concerns a failure to expand conventional supply again after the third quarter of 2025. The court presented these points as plaintiffs’ allegations, whose plausibility it assessed at this stage, not as established final facts.
The complaint also relies on announcements by the three companies of plans to cut production of mainstream DDR4 in 2025, which the court said were made roughly between April and June of that year. The court found the claim plausible in light of continued DDR4 use, alongside what the complaint described as a price reversal between DDR4 and DDR5. That puts the conventional memory market at the center of the dispute, alongside the alleged shift toward higher-performance products. The case links production decisions with product mix, but does not determine whether those decisions resulted from illegal coordination or independent commercial responses. That distinction will remain a legal focus as the case proceeds.
Price data provides background on volatility in the DDR4 market in 2025. TrendForce said the average spot price of a key DDR4 chip rose from $2.180 to $2.460 in the week ended May 28, an increase of 12.8% week on week. The firm added at the time that the pace of spot price increases was expected to ease by the third quarter. In July 2025, TrendForce forecast that average contract prices for conventional DRAM would rise between 10% and 15% in the third quarter, citing suppliers’ shift toward higher-quality products and plans to end DDR4 and LPDDR4X production. These indicators appear in the context of the case as background on the memory market and do not in themselves constitute evidence of an agreement among the companies.
The importance of supply-demand balance is also tied to industry expectations for memory demand. In prepared remarks for its fiscal third-quarter earnings call on June 24, 2026, Micron said it expected supply and demand for both DRAM and NAND to remain tight beyond calendar year 2027. The company attributed its forecast to long-term demand and constraints on supply growth. That forecast sets ongoing market needs against allegations of production cuts and capacity shifts toward HBM. But it remains a forecast publicly stated by Micron and does not resolve the lawsuit’s claims or the dispute over the companies’ market conduct.
The court’s order set December 7, 2026, as the deadline for the three companies to answer the complaint and January 12, 2027, for a case management conference. The case will thus move to procedural responses after the motion to dismiss was rejected. The order did not provide for discovery to begin, so the next clear steps are the companies’ responses and the court conference. Those dates will allow observers to follow how the parties address the allegations concerning production cuts, the shift to HBM and the exit from older DDR products. The November 14 ruling did not decide legal liability.