EL7.AI
StocksMedium•16 November 2026•
4 min read

TCIM’s 4.65% Stake in Voya Puts Glass Lewis Recommendation Under Scrutiny

Key Facts

1TCIM manages funds with an economic stake of approximately 4.65% in Voya and disagrees with Glass Lewis’s recommendation on the resolution.
2The virtual meeting on the resolution is scheduled for November 24, 2026, at 11:00 a.m. Eastern Time.
3Net income available to common shareholders was $193 million in the third quarter of 2026, compared with $176 million in the third quarter of 2025.
4Voya increased its share repurchase authorization by $500 million in its November 2, 2026 announcement.

In a statement issued on November 16, TCIM Management said it manages funds representing an economic stake of approximately 4.65% in Voya Financial and disagrees with Glass Lewis’s recommendation on a vote of no confidence in the company’s management. TCIM quoted the adviser’s report as saying that weak historical performance and a mixed strategic execution record provide a reasonable basis for its criticism. But that acknowledgment of some of the investor’s arguments does not mean Glass Lewis recommended voting in favor of the resolution; TCIM said it disagrees with the adviser’s recommendation. That distinction puts the adviser’s position at the center of the shareholder campaign: the report addresses the grounds for criticism and strategic options, while its recommendation on the vote differs from TCIM’s position. Shareholders are scheduled to discuss the resolution at a virtual meeting on November 24.

According to excerpts from the report cited by TCIM, Glass Lewis said Voya has generally lagged its peers in total shareholder return and that its relative value has declined substantially. The excerpt said the company had missed some operating and acquisition expectations. It specifically cited Benefitfocus and the large-case medical stop-loss business as areas where some expectations were not met. The adviser, as quoted by TCIM, said these observations support the existence of grounds for the investor’s criticism of performance and execution. It also linked the criticism to the company’s strategic record, rather than to the results of a single quarter, describing that record as mixed.

The discussion also concerns Voya’s ownership prospects. Glass Lewis said the sector’s recent wave of consolidation and reports of potential acquisition interest in the company strengthen the case for TCIM’s proposal. TCIM’s statement said Voya told the adviser it remained open to credible acquisition offers. It added, however, that the company had not commented on any specific offers or communications. According to the published excerpt, Glass Lewis said considering strategic alternatives could help compare the potential value of selling the company or some of its businesses with continuing to execute independently. TCIM said the adviser favored exploring these alternatives while taking into account the possibility that announcing a sale process could disrupt the company’s business.

The debate follows mixed results between the second and third quarters of 2026. Net income available to common shareholders was $193 million in the third quarter, compared with $176 million in the same period of 2025, while adjusted operating earnings after tax rose to $240 million from $239 million. In the second quarter, adjusted operating earnings after tax had fallen to $140 million, compared with $240 million in the second quarter of 2025. Voya attributed that decline mainly to lower alternative investment income and severance expenses. When it reported third-quarter results, CEO Heather Lavallee said the company had recorded commercial momentum in retirement and investment management, continued improvement in employee benefits margins, and discipline in expense management.

Voya also announced on November 2 a 21% increase in its quarterly cash dividend to $0.57 per share and raised its share repurchase authorization by $500 million. These decisions provide additional context for the contrast between the performance indicators presented by the company and TCIM’s criticism of relative performance and strategic execution. The proposed vote is legally nonbinding, and its approval would not impose any legal obligation on the board or the company to take action. TCIM will not hold the vote unless those present or represented by proxy account for at least one-third of the voting power of the outstanding shares. An appendix to the proxy statement says 89,655,438 common shares were outstanding and eligible to vote on September 30, 2026.

The definitive proxy statement set the virtual meeting for the vote on November 24, 2026, at 11:00 a.m. Eastern Time. The meeting will therefore measure participation and voting on the resolution, without itself creating an obligation for the board. If the vote is held, TCIM said it will publish the certified results and share them with Voya’s board and management within four business days of the vote. The company’s statement said investors with questions about voting can contact Okapi Partners. The statement provides the toll-free number (844) 343-2621.

Open on chart