Ledger confirms device implant as loss estimates may exceed $86 million
Key Facts
Ledger confirmed that an unauthorized physical implant had been found inside a device belonging to one affected user, amid estimates that losses could exceed $86 million, according to Cointelegraph. The publication attributed the loss estimate to researcher Specter, who said the losses spanned Bitcoin, Ethereum and Tron. The company's confirmation concerns the discovery of the implant inside a device, while the estimated financial value of the missing assets comes from the researcher. The company has not confirmed total losses or the number of affected customers as the investigation continues into the incident involving devices that reached users through the distribution chain. According to The Block, the loss estimates had not been independently confirmed.
In a subsequent update on the attack, Ledger said the attackers bought genuine devices, opened them and inserted hidden components before putting them back into circulation. The company said these components were designed to "capture the recovery phrase during setup," meaning while users were setting up the devices they had purchased. The modified devices were put back into circulation through resellers in Southeast Asia, according to the company's account of how they reached buyers. Regarding its central systems, Ledger said that "the company's infrastructure, systems and services have not been compromised." Its announcement about the implant therefore concerns physical tampering inside a user's device, alongside its denial that its services and systems had been compromised.
Reseller CryptoBilis had been linked to the investigation into the loss of funds, according to Cointelegraph's coverage of Ledger's initial response to the incident. CryptoBilis was listed as an authorized reseller of the company's devices in Indonesia, Malaysia and the Philippines, the markets covered by its authorized reseller listing. In its initial assessment, Ledger described the incident as appearing to be isolated and linked to a single reseller, while the investigation was still underway. In its subsequent update, it said it had asked authorized resellers to "suspend sales in Southeast Asia and Hong Kong." The suspension request thus covered the company's authorized resellers in the region specified in the update, including Hong Kong.
As background on device authenticity checks, Ledger's Donjon laboratory explains that the check does not detect all forms of physical modification that can be made to a device. The laboratory says the authenticity check "cannot detect unauthorized physical modifications, such as spy implants, if the original secure element remains intact." This qualification ties the check's capabilities to the condition of the original chip, even when components have been added to the rest of the hardware. On distribution, Ledger's safe purchasing guidelines set out a contractual obligation concerning devices that buyers return to retail partners. The company says its agreements prohibit those partners from returning devices to stock and reselling them.
Ledger previously announced that it had detected an exploit of the Connect Kit library on December 14, 2023, according to its security report on that incident. Its review said malicious code had been injected into decentralized applications as part of that software exploit. The code was designed to trick users into signing transactions that drained their assets, according to the company's description of how the earlier attack was carried out. In a message about the incident, Ledger Chairman and Chief Executive Pascal Gauthier said the exploit "did not and does not affect the integrity of Ledger hardware or Ledger Live." The current incident, by contrast, involves hidden components physically added to genuine devices to capture recovery phrases during setup, according to the company's subsequent update.
As part of its response to the physical attack, Ledger announced new requirements for how its products are stored and handed over at resellers' retail outlets. It said products "should no longer be placed on shelves or in display units," with inventory kept at the back of the store. The announced arrangements require the device to be handed to the buyer when the purchase is completed, rather than kept on display on shelves. For those who have already set up their devices, The Block reported Ledger's advice to consider moving assets to a new device from the company. The advice specified that the new device should come with a new recovery phrase, alongside replacing the device used to hold the assets.